4,833
edits
Changes
From TheBookbag
Jump to navigationJump to searchRed Cat, Blue Cat by Jenni Desmond (view source)
Revision as of 21:57, 5 November 2012
, 21:57, 5 November 2012no edit summary
|title=Red Cat, Blue Cat
|sort=Red Cat, Blue Cat
|author=Jenni DemondDesmond
|reviewer=Keith Dudhnath
|genre=For Sharing
Red Cat and Blue Cat don't get on. They don't get on at all. They hiss and scratch and stumble and thwump. They fight like... well, cat and cat. Each cat has a secret, though: each cat would quite like to be like the other. Blue Cat would like to be fast and bouncy like Red Cat, and Red Cat would like to be smart and quick-witted like Blue Cat. Blue Cat tries to turn red, by eating red things. Red Cat copies him. Neither changes colour, and neither takes on the characteristics of the other. Who'd have thunk it? They're going to have to come up with another plan.
Much of ''Red Cat , Blue Cat'' is great fun. The illustrations are packed with character, and have a really enjoyable style. I particularly loved seeing red cat diving into the blue jelly! The core idea of two battling cats at each other's throats, and then ultimately finding friendship, is a great one. The execution, particularly towards the end, lacks a little something. The friendship plans don't always hit the mark: Red Cat's attempts at smart ideas aren't either clear enough or as funny as the earlier scenes. The final twist, with the addition of another cat, ends on an unsatisfying and confusing note, rather than the amusing conclusion it could have been.
The writing is a similar mix of very good, and promising touches. When everything clicks with the illustrations - such as when Red Cat eats ''certain cupcakes'' - it's top notch. However, when the story drifts towards the end, the writing doesn't hold together quite as well. I'd be interested to see what Jenni Desmond produces in the future - the illustrations are of the highest standard, and it wouldn't take much more to have the writing up to a similar quality.
