132,583
edits
Changes
From TheBookbag
Jump to navigationJump to searchThe Private Blog of Joe Cowley by Ben Davis (view source)
Revision as of 13:22, 22 August 2020
, 13:22, 22 August 2020no edit summary
|aznus=0192736752
|cover=0192736752
|summary=Sterling work, if only for being fresh and different enough to fill a real gap in the market – although its merits don't end there.
}}
It is quite ridiculous to state this, but it might as well be fact and not just my opinion – this book is targeted at a huge gap in the market, and luckily enough for us all is good enough to fill it singlehandedly. This is the teenage blog that, given a few years, the readers of [[:Category:Jeff Kinney|the Wimpy Kid]] will grow to need as their favourite reading. This is the male reader's equivalent of the equally brilliant [[:Category:Joanna Nadin|Rachel Riley diaries]]. This is just a brilliant amalgamation of theatre of embarrassment, with a sympathetic yet engaging lead, a realistic and entertaining narrative voice, and a full-on sense of humour.
I know what you're thinking from seeing the cover – that puff about it being the 'funniest book you'll read this year'. Of course , it's a stupid idea, a nonsensical comment, but if anything this book is closest to deserving the hyperbole. The great thing about the comedy here is its very intelligence; the sense of humour is wide-ranging, from the callback stretched over what might actually be far too long a reading time, to the immediate, punchy quip. I might be more accurate than the designers by saying this is the funniest teen read for guys out there, but as I say, the market was so bereft that's a bit of a moot point. What’s a delight to report is that it is almost as humorous as the publishers pretend – and in a real teen-friendly way. There are willy jokes, laughs to stretch the norm of YA writing, and more – even a very undersold double entendre on page 306 of my proof copy that got a thumbs up by itself.
Yes, there are definitely things here that younger readers that will have witnessed by now – problems with zits, problems with idiot friends and idiot parents, problems with life itself. But this book successfully stretches things as regards willies, parental sex and the use of ''cocking'' as a cussing adjective to make this definitely a teen-only read. And it's all the better for it. What that does mean is I'm left with the sneaky suspicion that the greater arc of the story, the whole rise-before-the-fall, and the ridiculous plot device of a home-made computer projection, might be a bit too silly and a little too bloody obvious for the target audience. But again I'm on the side of this book as being so wanted and so necessary for this audience that I can't really mark it down.
I do think the format isn't addressed completely perfectly – some of the blog entries have the snappiness of real life, some go on and on, written from the emotional safety of the day after, and must have taken the lad Joe hours and hours to type. To repeat, there is a case to be had for it being a tad too long, if only for some the jokes. I also think that, just as with Rachel Riley, the author is putting too much of his own tastes and experiences into things – Skyping takes a large place in the plot, and there is a brilliant joke against pop star Usher, but there are also references when relevant to A Flock of Seagulls, and Trekker-out-of-his-time Joe's favourite band is a risible and unlikely Pink Floyd, which shows our author's own taste and age bracket more than anything. So the cultural references aren't great, but aside from that , I think the author and his debut in this series really has hit the ground running. Joe and the weird voices in the control room in his head deserve many more volumes, and so does this limited category of YA titles. An essential read for a neglected audience.
I must thank the publishers for my review copy. With all the excitement about Joe Cowley, please don't forget [[Danny Dread by Ben Davis|Danny Dread]].
[[Rock War by Robert Muchamore]] is the start of a different kind of teen series, from a much more experienced author.
