4,833
edits
Changes
From TheBookbag
Jump to navigationJump to searchWildwood Dancing by Juliet Marillier (view source)
Revision as of 09:23, 13 September 2009
, 09:23, 13 September 2009no edit summary
{{infobox
|title=Wildwood Dancing
|author=Juliet Marillier
|reviewer=Magda Healey
|genre=Teens
|summary=An enchanting story of love, peril and family bonds in the atmospheric setting of a Transylvanian castle and forest, this competent novel is not exactly breaking new ground, but it's a decent piece of entertainment and will be enjoyed by all readers who enjoy a faerie tales, from teenagers to adults.
|rating=3.5
|buy=No
|borrow=Yes
|format=Paperback
|pages=288
|publisher=Tor
|date=7 Dec 2007
|isbn=978-0330438285
|amazonuk=<amazonuk>033043828X</amazonuk>
|amazonus=<amazonus>0375833641</amazonus>
}}
''Wildwood Dancing'' belongs to a genre called, for some reason, Young
Adult even though it would be better defined as older teen as YA books
usually feature characters that are aged 15+ and often (if not always)
concern themselves with formative experiences, coming of age, sexual and
romantic awakenings and other subjects of major interest to older teenagers
but also capable of engaging a not-so-young-adult.
And so with ''Wildwood Dancing'': an atmospheric fairy fantasy set in
remote Transylvania in time unspecified. Janica, Tatiana, Iulia, Paul and Stella are merchant daughters and sisters, living in a castle called Piscul Dracului (Devil's or Dragon's Step: these terms are, apparently interchangeable in Romanian). The castle stands on the edge of a mysterious wildwood, which the valley people treat with respect and fear. The girls have a secret: every Full Moon they leave their bedroom using a secret, magical portal and dance the night away in the Other Kingdom: a strange, wondrous and slightly scary world sharing some aspects of space and time with the human world, but set apart. The trouble
starts when the girls' father gets ill and has to leave the valley for the
winter. Their cousin Cezar starts taking over, despite the girls' father
leaving the running of the household and business to them. To add to the
troubles, The Night People have appeared at the dancing glade in the Other
Kingdom, and the eldest sister Tati has fallen for somebody they brought
with them.
I wasn't particularly drawn into the ''Wildwood Dancing'' at first.
The writing seemed a bit pedestrian, and the story commonplace (as far as a
faerie story can be a commonplace one), with not much ahppening and nothing
in the scene-setting to make up for this lack of action. But as the events
gathered speed and the dilemmas faced by the girls became more serious, I
started enjoying the tale. The characters are well differentiated,
especially the sisters: the scholarly Paula, the desperately romantic,
beautiful Tati, flirty Iulia and Jena herself, the sensible, businesslike
one, the one on whose shoulders the main responsibility for the whole family
lies, the one who will have to make the moral decisions, and the one who
narrates the story.
The romance and growing up are the main focus of the tale, while the
good-against-evil drama of the classic fantasy is somehow absent. But there
is love and despair, faith and desire, trust and responsibility that all of
the girls learn, while the subject of the relationship with the Other
Kingdom can be easily interpreted as reflecting our relationship with
nature. I also liked the fairies, witches and other fey creatures in
''Wildwood Dancing'': they were neither completely bad or completely
good, with various realms within the Other Kingdom and even the vampire-like
Night People not entirely evil, though seemed to veer quite close to it.
With its unusual setting and a mixture of magic, dramatic romance, nods to
ecology and vaguely Eastern-European folklore (though in all honesty, apart
from the names and possibly the chief witch Draguta, nothing seemed very far
off the standard faerie imagery), ''Wildwood Dancing'' is a pleasant,
competently written fairy fantasy, perfectly suitable for its target
audience and might be enjoyed, but will be probably quickly forgotten, by
all fans of the genre.
If you like that, you might also enjoy a more modern take on similar themes
in [[Wicked Lovely]] while adult fantasy readers with
a penchant for fey creatures might like a grittier coming of age tale set in
a nightmarish Faerie [[The Iron Dragon's Daughter]] or the stylish pastiche of [[Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrel]] by Susanna Clarke. For a younger audience, a brilliant Romanian-set story of the supernatural can be found in [[My Swordhand is Singing]].
{{amazontext|amazon=033043828X}}
'''Reviews of other books by Juliet Marillier'''
[[Cybele's Secret]]
{{commenthead}}
|title=Wildwood Dancing
|author=Juliet Marillier
|reviewer=Magda Healey
|genre=Teens
|summary=An enchanting story of love, peril and family bonds in the atmospheric setting of a Transylvanian castle and forest, this competent novel is not exactly breaking new ground, but it's a decent piece of entertainment and will be enjoyed by all readers who enjoy a faerie tales, from teenagers to adults.
|rating=3.5
|buy=No
|borrow=Yes
|format=Paperback
|pages=288
|publisher=Tor
|date=7 Dec 2007
|isbn=978-0330438285
|amazonuk=<amazonuk>033043828X</amazonuk>
|amazonus=<amazonus>0375833641</amazonus>
}}
''Wildwood Dancing'' belongs to a genre called, for some reason, Young
Adult even though it would be better defined as older teen as YA books
usually feature characters that are aged 15+ and often (if not always)
concern themselves with formative experiences, coming of age, sexual and
romantic awakenings and other subjects of major interest to older teenagers
but also capable of engaging a not-so-young-adult.
And so with ''Wildwood Dancing'': an atmospheric fairy fantasy set in
remote Transylvania in time unspecified. Janica, Tatiana, Iulia, Paul and Stella are merchant daughters and sisters, living in a castle called Piscul Dracului (Devil's or Dragon's Step: these terms are, apparently interchangeable in Romanian). The castle stands on the edge of a mysterious wildwood, which the valley people treat with respect and fear. The girls have a secret: every Full Moon they leave their bedroom using a secret, magical portal and dance the night away in the Other Kingdom: a strange, wondrous and slightly scary world sharing some aspects of space and time with the human world, but set apart. The trouble
starts when the girls' father gets ill and has to leave the valley for the
winter. Their cousin Cezar starts taking over, despite the girls' father
leaving the running of the household and business to them. To add to the
troubles, The Night People have appeared at the dancing glade in the Other
Kingdom, and the eldest sister Tati has fallen for somebody they brought
with them.
I wasn't particularly drawn into the ''Wildwood Dancing'' at first.
The writing seemed a bit pedestrian, and the story commonplace (as far as a
faerie story can be a commonplace one), with not much ahppening and nothing
in the scene-setting to make up for this lack of action. But as the events
gathered speed and the dilemmas faced by the girls became more serious, I
started enjoying the tale. The characters are well differentiated,
especially the sisters: the scholarly Paula, the desperately romantic,
beautiful Tati, flirty Iulia and Jena herself, the sensible, businesslike
one, the one on whose shoulders the main responsibility for the whole family
lies, the one who will have to make the moral decisions, and the one who
narrates the story.
The romance and growing up are the main focus of the tale, while the
good-against-evil drama of the classic fantasy is somehow absent. But there
is love and despair, faith and desire, trust and responsibility that all of
the girls learn, while the subject of the relationship with the Other
Kingdom can be easily interpreted as reflecting our relationship with
nature. I also liked the fairies, witches and other fey creatures in
''Wildwood Dancing'': they were neither completely bad or completely
good, with various realms within the Other Kingdom and even the vampire-like
Night People not entirely evil, though seemed to veer quite close to it.
With its unusual setting and a mixture of magic, dramatic romance, nods to
ecology and vaguely Eastern-European folklore (though in all honesty, apart
from the names and possibly the chief witch Draguta, nothing seemed very far
off the standard faerie imagery), ''Wildwood Dancing'' is a pleasant,
competently written fairy fantasy, perfectly suitable for its target
audience and might be enjoyed, but will be probably quickly forgotten, by
all fans of the genre.
If you like that, you might also enjoy a more modern take on similar themes
in [[Wicked Lovely]] while adult fantasy readers with
a penchant for fey creatures might like a grittier coming of age tale set in
a nightmarish Faerie [[The Iron Dragon's Daughter]] or the stylish pastiche of [[Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrel]] by Susanna Clarke. For a younger audience, a brilliant Romanian-set story of the supernatural can be found in [[My Swordhand is Singing]].
{{amazontext|amazon=033043828X}}
'''Reviews of other books by Juliet Marillier'''
[[Cybele's Secret]]
{{commenthead}}
