132,613
edits
Changes
Snatch by Gregory Mcdonald (view source)
Revision as of 17:29, 27 January 2017
, 17:29, 27 January 2017Created page with "{{infobox |title=Snatch |author=Gregory Mcdonald |reviewer=Sam Tyler |genre=Crime |summary=Not one, but two, stories about kidnapping. Similar premises, but different books...."
{{infobox
|title=Snatch
|author=Gregory Mcdonald
|reviewer=Sam Tyler
|genre=Crime
|summary=Not one, but two, stories about kidnapping. Similar premises, but different books. Why not try them out as they are the type of pulp writing you are unlikely to find many other places?
|rating=3.5
|buy=Maybe
|borrow=Yes
|pages=448
|publisher=Hard Case Crime
|date=February 2017
|isbn=9781785651823
|website=http://www.gregorymcdonald.com/
|video=
|amazonuk=<amazonuk>178565182X</amazonuk>
}}
It's not often that you get two books for the price of one, but if you are going to see this anywhere it will likely be in a reissue. Taking the back catalogue of an author and compiling a larger book consisting of similar stories is a great way of reusing stock that you already have. Hard Case Crime have done this with two books by ''Fletch'' author Gregory Mcdonald. Surely two books that centre on kidnapping by the same author would be similar enough to be placed together? Think again.
The first story centres on the taking of Toby Rinaldi, the son of a diplomat and was originally known as ''Who Took Toby Rinaldi?'' The second is the misadventures and kidnapping of a young Duke during the Second World War, originally called ''Safekeeping''. Both have victims who are young precocious boys who have been schooled privately, but from there the books have little in common. One has classic style pulp thrills, whilst the other attempts to be far more humorous.
''Snatch'' is a solo affair that contains a duo of novels that would have perhaps have been better left separate. Taken on their own, each has elements going for it. The stronger title is ''Rinaldi'' as it plays the thrills straight and is a good slice of pulp fiction. The book does have a little comedy of errors within it, but the mistakes are not meant to be funny, but make the chances of Toby's rescue less likely. The action sequence towards the end of the book is particularly good as it takes place in an amusement park overnight and into the early morning. Seeing the wonder of a theme park through the eyes of the child, juxtaposed with the threat of death, works really well and is the type of thing you only find in vintage pulp such as this.
On the surface ''Safekeeping'' should follow the same pattern – same age child, same view of a dangerous world through a child's eyes, but the tone is different. Whilst ''Rinaldi'' is a straight thriller, ''Safekeeping'' is far broader and attempts over the top characters. The WW2 setting makes it an interesting read in places, but the larger than life characters means that it feels like an unfunny broad comedy. It is particularly jarring towards the end of the book when immense violence if undertaken by an otherwise clownish man. Is this a comedy or a thriller? It struggles to be either.
On its own ''Rinaldi'' could have been reissued as ''Snatch'' and fans of pulp fiction and Mcdonald's ''Fletch'' novel would have been happy. As it is, that book needs to carry the second story, that has an interesting historic setting, but a comedic bent that does not hit home. The two stories together just don't really fit – no characters are in both and the settings are different. In this case the parts are superior to the whole, but still worth a read for pulp fan as ''Rinaldi'' in particular has the type of scenes in it that you will only get from this type of reissued vintage pulp.
Hard Case Crime have reissued some great pulp fiction is recent years including [[Quarry's List by Max Allan Collins]] and [[So Nude, So Dead by Ed McBain]]
{{amazontext|amazon=178565182X}}
{{amazonUStext|amazon=178565182X}}
{{commenthead}}
|title=Snatch
|author=Gregory Mcdonald
|reviewer=Sam Tyler
|genre=Crime
|summary=Not one, but two, stories about kidnapping. Similar premises, but different books. Why not try them out as they are the type of pulp writing you are unlikely to find many other places?
|rating=3.5
|buy=Maybe
|borrow=Yes
|pages=448
|publisher=Hard Case Crime
|date=February 2017
|isbn=9781785651823
|website=http://www.gregorymcdonald.com/
|video=
|amazonuk=<amazonuk>178565182X</amazonuk>
}}
It's not often that you get two books for the price of one, but if you are going to see this anywhere it will likely be in a reissue. Taking the back catalogue of an author and compiling a larger book consisting of similar stories is a great way of reusing stock that you already have. Hard Case Crime have done this with two books by ''Fletch'' author Gregory Mcdonald. Surely two books that centre on kidnapping by the same author would be similar enough to be placed together? Think again.
The first story centres on the taking of Toby Rinaldi, the son of a diplomat and was originally known as ''Who Took Toby Rinaldi?'' The second is the misadventures and kidnapping of a young Duke during the Second World War, originally called ''Safekeeping''. Both have victims who are young precocious boys who have been schooled privately, but from there the books have little in common. One has classic style pulp thrills, whilst the other attempts to be far more humorous.
''Snatch'' is a solo affair that contains a duo of novels that would have perhaps have been better left separate. Taken on their own, each has elements going for it. The stronger title is ''Rinaldi'' as it plays the thrills straight and is a good slice of pulp fiction. The book does have a little comedy of errors within it, but the mistakes are not meant to be funny, but make the chances of Toby's rescue less likely. The action sequence towards the end of the book is particularly good as it takes place in an amusement park overnight and into the early morning. Seeing the wonder of a theme park through the eyes of the child, juxtaposed with the threat of death, works really well and is the type of thing you only find in vintage pulp such as this.
On the surface ''Safekeeping'' should follow the same pattern – same age child, same view of a dangerous world through a child's eyes, but the tone is different. Whilst ''Rinaldi'' is a straight thriller, ''Safekeeping'' is far broader and attempts over the top characters. The WW2 setting makes it an interesting read in places, but the larger than life characters means that it feels like an unfunny broad comedy. It is particularly jarring towards the end of the book when immense violence if undertaken by an otherwise clownish man. Is this a comedy or a thriller? It struggles to be either.
On its own ''Rinaldi'' could have been reissued as ''Snatch'' and fans of pulp fiction and Mcdonald's ''Fletch'' novel would have been happy. As it is, that book needs to carry the second story, that has an interesting historic setting, but a comedic bent that does not hit home. The two stories together just don't really fit – no characters are in both and the settings are different. In this case the parts are superior to the whole, but still worth a read for pulp fan as ''Rinaldi'' in particular has the type of scenes in it that you will only get from this type of reissued vintage pulp.
Hard Case Crime have reissued some great pulp fiction is recent years including [[Quarry's List by Max Allan Collins]] and [[So Nude, So Dead by Ed McBain]]
{{amazontext|amazon=178565182X}}
{{amazonUStext|amazon=178565182X}}
{{commenthead}}