132,613
edits
Changes
Hitler's Furies: German Women in the Nazi Killing Fields by Wendy Lower (view source)
Revision as of 08:33, 2 September 2020
, 08:33, 2 September 2020no edit summary
From that you can tell there are galling details about the events of the time in these pages – how could there not be. Women, even ones who later testified to being pregnant and therefore the epitome of feminine Nazi ideals, were bashing Jewish babies' heads against walls, shooting Jews alongside their husbands, and more. But again my problems with the book met with the style the author uses. The first chapter was so wishy-washy it hardly informed me at all, beyond a slight vindication of the book's existence. The second seemed too quick to say 'someone said this', 'someone did that', and yet to fail to meet the historian's need (beyond the hugely extensive notes at the back) to say who and where. Only after that do we meet some case studies, who are hard to latch on to and keep separate as far as the later stages of the book, where the big questions get rhetorically asked too early on, meaning the end again drifts away from the immediacy I sought.
So the book falls between two stools – I could always read and understand every page, and for the student there are the notes that make the book a whole fifth longer again on their own. But it didn't read either as academic as perhaps some would wish, nor as easily and forcefully as I wanted or expected from the copious blurbs that use their own powerful, stunning and evocative adjectives about the book. And with that looseness I identified at the beginning, when the obvious yet unseen facts of womanhood in 1930s Germany and beyond were roughly sketched for us, I did see some people losing interest. The fact remains that this book gives a welcome recap of Nazi history in galling detail, as usual, and covers the whole gamut of its subject from what made a German woman in that time, to how they didn't get the justice due them after the war, again due to their gender. But by my rules that mean I seek a non-fiction book that tells an ideal story in the an ideal way with the voice of the perfect writer, this book failed. It informed, but it lacked something – something perhaps I dare to call masculine.
I must thank the publisher for my review copy.
[[Hitler's Last Witness: The Memoirs of Hitler's Bodyguard by Rochus Misch]] takes us adeptly through Nazi times from the point of view of the Fuhrer's lackey. [[Magda by Meike Ziervogel]] fictionalises Mrs Goebbels but still manages to show how some women thought and acted under Nazi flags. You might also appreciate [[Hitler at Home by Despina Stratigakos]].
{{amazontext|amazon=0099572281}}