Winger by Andrew Smith - Revision history

Sue at 08:24, 24 April 2018

2018-04-24T08:24:49Z

Sue at 21:45, 6 February 2018

2018-02-06T21:45:06Z

Sue at 11:41, 29 November 2014

2014-11-29T11:41:22Z

Sue: Created page with "{{infobox |title=Winger |author=Andrew Smith |reviewer=Robert James |genre=Teens |rating=2.5 |buy=No |borrow=No |isbn=978-0141354743 |pages=448 |publisher=Penguin |date=June 2..."

2014-07-04T08:43:16Z

Created page with "{{infobox |title=Winger |author=Andrew Smith |reviewer=Robert James |genre=Teens |rating=2.5 |buy=No |borrow=No |isbn=978-0141354743 |pages=448 |publisher=Penguin |date=June 2..."

New review

{{infobox
|title=Winger
|author=Andrew Smith
|reviewer=Robert James
|genre=Teens
|rating=2.5
|buy=No
|borrow=No
|isbn=978-0141354743
|pages=448
|publisher=Penguin
|date=June 2014
|amazonuk=<amazonuk>0141354747</amazonuk>
|amazonus=<amazonus>0141354747</amazonus>
|website=http://www.authorandrewsmith.com
|video=
|summary=Hugely disappointing with flat characters and none of the flair shown in Smith's wonderful [[Grasshopper Jungle by Andrew Smith|Grasshopper Jungle]].
}}
Fourteen-year-old Ryan Dean West is at boarding school. His roommate is a bully, his closest male friends are idiots, and his best friend is an older girl he's madly in love with who doesn't seem to see him in the same way. But this could be a year that changes everything for him.

I don't get this. At all. I don't see how the same mind that created the breathtakingly, brilliantly, beguiling [[Grasshopper Jungle by Andrew Smith|Grasshopper Jungle]] could have come up with this book. And I definitely don't see why so many people are finding this one so great. Where Grasshopper Jungle had style, flair and humour, this has leaden prose, dull characters, and the only thing to laugh at is the idea that anyone could find Ryan Dean attractive when he has all the personality of a rugby ball. That said, nearly all of the other characters are dreadfully boring as well, with perhaps the only one I found reasonably convincing to be Ryan Dean's gay friend Joey, so maybe everyone deserves each other.

In addition, so many little things about this book were hugely irritating - I'm not sure whether the worst offender was Ryan Dean's constant babbling about not swearing, in between swearing, or his quotes of things people said to him only to follow up with the real version of what they said. I forced myself to read through it to the end simply because I loved Grasshopper Jungle so much that I thought it had to get better, but it didn't. The ending is one which some may describe as powerful but it's so rushed - especially considering the massive length of the book, which goes on for nearly 400 pages before we really get to anything interesting happening - and so obvious when it finally arrives, that it's difficult to feel any emotion about it.

On the plus side, I liked the comic strips. Overall, though, not the worst book of the year so far but, given the amount of great reviews I've seen and just how amazing I found Grasshopper Jungle to be, almost certainly the most disappointing.

I think that you should definitely try Smith's other much-praised novel, [[Grasshopper Jungle by Andrew Smith|Grasshopper Jungle]]. For more about boys coming of age, I'd recommend [[Geekhood: Mission Improbable by Andy Robb]] and [[Boys Don't Knit by T S Easton]].

{{amazontext|amazon=0141354747}}
{{commenthead}}

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:41, 29 November 2014
Line 28:		Line 28:

	{{amazontext\|amazon=0141354747}}		{{amazontext\|amazon=0141354747}}
		+	{{amazonUStext\|amazon=0141354747}}
		+
	{{commenthead}}		{{commenthead}}

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-{{infobox
+{{infobox1
 |title=Winger
 |author=Andrew Smith
@@ Line 11: / Line 11: @@
 |publisher=Penguin
 |date=June 2014
-|amazonuk=<amazonuk>0141354747</amazonuk>
+|amazonuk=<amazonuk></amazonuk>
 |website=http://www.authorandrewsmith.com
 |summary=Hugely disappointing with flat characters and none of the flair shown in Smith's wonderful [[Grasshopper Jungle by Andrew Smith|Grasshopper Jungle]].
 }}
 Fourteen-year-old Ryan Dean West is at boarding school. His roommate is a bully, his closest male friends are idiots, and his best friend is an older girl he's madly in love with who doesn't seem to see him in the same way. But this could be a year that changes everything for him.