The 19th Wife by David Ebershoff - Revision history

Sue at 15:26, 12 October 2020

2020-10-12T15:26:09Z

Sue at 10:05, 7 October 2020

2020-10-07T10:05:55Z

Sue at 15:27, 10 August 2020

2020-08-10T15:27:25Z

Sue at 14:09, 28 February 2018

2018-02-28T14:09:13Z

Sue at 16:51, 12 November 2014

2014-11-12T16:51:01Z

Sue at 18:23, 21 November 2012

2012-11-21T18:23:39Z

Keith: 1 revision

2009-10-24T17:15:13Z

1 revision

Sue at 08:29, 1 June 2009

2009-06-01T08:29:06Z

New review

{{infoboxsort
|title=The 19th Wife
|author=David Ebershoff
|reviewer=Paul Curd
|genre=General Fiction
|summary=Two novels in one – a modern murder mystery intertwined with a fictional reworking of history – set in the Mormon world of polygamy. Very interesting in some places, but not as good a read as I'd been led to believe by the Richard and Judy blurb. Possibly over-ambitious and ultimately disappointing.
|rating=3.5
|buy=No
|borrow=Yes
|format=Paperback
|pages=608
|publisher= Black Swan
|date=January 2009
|isbn=978-0552774987
|amazonuk=<amazonuk>0552774987</amazonuk>
|amazonus=<amazonus>0812974158</amazonus>
|sort=19th Wife
}}

David Ebershoff's latest novel, ''The 19th Wife'', develops two parallel stories, one of them a fictionalized account of historical fact, the other a modern day murder mystery. Both revolve around polygamy and the Mormons, and both involve a 19th wife. The first of these wives is Ann Eliza Young, the real-life 19th spouse of the real-life 19th Century Mormon prophet Brigham Young. The second 19th wife is the mother of our modern-day narrator, Jordan Scott. Jordan's mother has been accused of murdering his father. He is sure she must be innocent, and decides to penetrate the closed society that rejected him in order to discover the truth.

The parts of the book dealing with Ann Eliza Young take in the whole history of the Mormons, from their establishment and early clashes with the Authorities — including the Haun's Mill Massacre, in which many of their number were murdered with the approval of the state government — until their final settlement in Utah. Ann's personal story takes us through her unhappy marriage to one man, her divorce and subsequent 'marriage' as the 19th wife of Brigham Young, a man who receives messages directly from God. Eventually, Ann breaks free of the prophet's hold, seeks a divorce and begins a public campaign against the evils of polygamy.

In telling this part of the story, Ebershoff has constructed fictional texts, diaries, memoirs, legal depositions, letters, newspaper articles, and even a cod Wikipedia entry. We are presented with accounts by Ann herself, by Ann's father, Chauncey, by her brother Gilbert, by Brigham Young himself, by various others. We are shown a college dissertation and Mormon sermons. Ebershoff has clearly done an awful lot of research (and there's an extensive bibliography to prove it) and most of his constructions therefore come across as very realistic. The result, unfortunately, is that they can also come across as a little dull (at least for this reviewer).

More interesting, at least at first, is the 21st Century story. Ebershoff's narrator, Jordon Scott, is a 20-year-old gay man who escaped the polygamous community where he grew up at the age of 14, when he was literally dumped at the side of the road by his mother. Jordon is a likeable, well-drawn character who sets out on his quest to prove his mother's innocence accompanied by his faithful dog Elektra, and with a lot of wry, understandably-bitter humour. Along the way, Jordon encounters various other characters, each with their own tale to tell. All these other 'voices', with Jordan's own memories, add another dimension to the realities of life within a polygamous community.

Quite soon, though, this modern murder mystery began to pall. There simply isn't enough suspense, and if it were a stand-alone novel, without the backdrop of Ann Eliza Young's story, there may not be enough narrative drive to keep the reader's interest going to the end. The further I got into this book, the more interested I became in the developing battle between Ann and Brigham Young, and the less interested I was in Jordan's modern-day quest. The question is, do these two interwoven stories make the whole novel work? Not, unfortunately, for this reviewer.

''The 19th Wife'' has been selected for the current Richard and Judy Book Club, so its sales are assured. Ebershoff has a lot of interesting things to say about religion in general, the Mormons specifically, and the whole question of polygamy in modern-day America. But I found the time shifts tended to break into the tension of both tales, and the weaknesses in the modern mystery were ultimately disappointing. And at 600 pages, these minor problems eventually became major irritations.

I'd like to thank the publishers for sending a copy to The Bookbag.

If this book has sparked your interest in Mormon Fundamentalism then try ''Under the Banner of Heaven: A Story of Violent Faith'' by Jon Krakauer. For an excellent combination of historical fiction and murder mystery take a look at [[The Suspicions of Mr Whicher by Kate Summerscale]].

{{amazontext|amazon=0552774987}} {{waterstonestext|waterstones=6519580}}

{{toptentext|list=Richard and Judy Shortlist 2009}}

{{commenthead}}
[[Category:Crime]][[Category:Historical Fiction]]

@@ Line 32: / Line 32: @@
 I'd like to thank the publishers for sending a copy to The Bookbag.
-You might enjoy [[The Bishop's Wife by Mette Ivie Harrison]]. If this book has sparked your interest in Mormon Fundamentalism then try ''Under the Banner of Heaven: A Story of Violent Faith'' by Jon Krakauer. For an excellent combination of historical fiction and murder mystery take a look at [[The Suspicions of Mr Whicher by Kate Summerscale]].  You might also enjoy [[Amity and Sorrow by Peggy Riley]].
+You might enjoy [[The Bishop's Wife by Mette Ivie Harrison]]. If this book has sparked your interest in Mormon Fundamentalism then try ''Under the Banner of Heaven: A Story of Violent Faith'' by Jon Krakauer. For an excellent combination of historical fiction and murder mystery take a look at [[The Suspicions of Mr Whicher by Kate Summerscale]].  You might also enjoy [[Amity and Sorrow by Peggy Riley]] and [[Sisterwives by Rachel Connor]].
 {{amazontext|amazon=0552774987}}

@@ Line 32: / Line 32: @@
 I'd like to thank the publishers for sending a copy to The Bookbag.
-If this book has sparked your interest in Mormon Fundamentalism then try ''Under the Banner of Heaven: A Story of Violent Faith'' by Jon Krakauer. For an excellent combination of historical fiction and murder mystery take a look at [[The Suspicions of Mr Whicher by Kate Summerscale]].  You might also enjoy [[Amity and Sorrow by Peggy Riley]].
+You might enjoy [[The Bishop's Wife by Mette Ivie Harrison]]. If this book has sparked your interest in Mormon Fundamentalism then try ''Under the Banner of Heaven: A Story of Violent Faith'' by Jon Krakauer. For an excellent combination of historical fiction and murder mystery take a look at [[The Suspicions of Mr Whicher by Kate Summerscale]].  You might also enjoy [[Amity and Sorrow by Peggy Riley]].
 {{amazontext|amazon=0552774987}}

@@ Line 18: / Line 18: @@
 }}
-David Ebershoff's latest novel, ''The 19th Wife'', develops two parallel stories, one of them a fictionalized account of historical fact, the other a modern day murder mystery. Both revolve around polygamy and the Mormons, and both involve a 19th wife. The first of these wives is Ann Eliza Young, the real-life 19th spouse of the real-life 19th Century Mormon prophet Brigham Young. The second 19th wife is the mother of our modern-day narrator, Jordan Scott. Jordan's mother has been accused of murdering his father. He is sure she must be innocent, and decides to penetrate the closed society that rejected him in order to discover the truth.
+David Ebershoff's latest novel, ''The 19th Wife'', develops two parallel stories, one of them a fictionalized account of historical fact, the other a modern-day murder mystery. Both revolve around polygamy and the Mormons, and both involve a 19th wife. The first of these wives is Ann Eliza Young, the real-life 19th spouse of the real-life 19th Century Mormon prophet Brigham Young. The second 19th wife is the mother of our modern-day narrator, Jordan Scott. Jordan's mother has been accused of murdering his father. He is sure she must be innocent and decides to penetrate the closed society that rejected him in order to discover the truth.
 The parts of the book dealing with Ann Eliza Young take in the whole history of the Mormons, from their establishment and early clashes with the Authorities — including the Haun's Mill Massacre, in which many of their number were murdered with the approval of the state government — until their final settlement in Utah. Ann's personal story takes us through her unhappy marriage to one man, her divorce and subsequent 'marriage' as the 19th wife of Brigham Young, a man who receives messages directly from God. Eventually, Ann breaks free of the prophet's hold, seeks a divorce and begins a public campaign against the evils of polygamy.
-In telling this part of the story, Ebershoff has constructed fictional texts, diaries, memoirs, legal depositions, letters, newspaper articles, and even a cod Wikipedia entry. We are presented with accounts by Ann herself, by Ann's father, Chauncey, by her brother Gilbert, by Brigham Young himself, by various others. We are shown a college dissertation and Mormon sermons. Ebershoff has clearly done an awful lot of research (and there's an extensive bibliography to prove it) and most of his constructions therefore come across as very realistic. The result, unfortunately, is that they can also come across as a little dull (at least for this reviewer).
+In telling this part of the story, Ebershoff has constructed fictional texts, diaries, memoirs, legal depositions, letters, newspaper articles, and even a cod Wikipedia entry. We are presented with accounts by Ann herself, by Ann's father, Chauncey, by her brother Gilbert, by Brigham Young himself, by various others. We are shown a college dissertation and Mormon sermons. Ebershoff has clearly done an awful lot of research (and there's an extensive bibliography to prove it) and most of his constructions, therefore, come across as very realistic. The result, unfortunately, is that they can also come across as a little dull (at least for this reviewer).
-More interesting, at least at first, is the 21st Century story. Ebershoff's narrator, Jordon Scott, is a 20-year-old gay man who escaped the polygamous community where he grew up at the age of 14, when he was literally dumped at the side of the road by his mother. Jordon is a likeable, well-drawn character who sets out on his quest to prove his mother's innocence accompanied by his faithful dog Elektra, and with a lot of wry, understandably-bitter humour. Along the way, Jordon encounters various other characters, each with their own tale to tell. All these other 'voices', with Jordan's own memories, add another dimension to the realities of life within a polygamous community.
+More interesting, at least at first, is the 21st Century story. Ebershoff's narrator, Jordon Scott, is a 20-year-old gay man who escaped the polygamous community where he grew up at the age of 14 when he was literally dumped at the side of the road by his mother. Jordon is a likeable, well-drawn character who sets out on his quest to prove his mother's innocence accompanied by his faithful dog Elektra, and with a lot of wry, understandably-bitter humour. Along the way, Jordon encounters various other characters, each with their own tale to tell. All these other 'voices', with Jordan's own memories, add another dimension to the realities of life within a polygamous community.
 Quite soon, though, this modern murder mystery began to pall. There simply isn't enough suspense, and if it were a stand-alone novel, without the backdrop of Ann Eliza Young's story, there may not be enough narrative drive to keep the reader's interest going to the end. The further I got into this book, the more interested I became in the developing battle between Ann and Brigham Young, and the less interested I was in Jordan's modern-day quest. The question is, do these two interwoven stories make the whole novel work? Not, unfortunately, for this reviewer.
@@ Line 32: / Line 32: @@
 I'd like to thank the publishers for sending a copy to The Bookbag.
-If this book has sparked your interest in Mormon Fundamentalism then try ''Under the Banner of Heaven: A Story of Violent Faith'' by Jon Krakauer. For an excellent combination of historical fiction and murder mystery take a look at [[The Suspicions of Mr Whicher by Kate Summerscale]].
+If this book has sparked your interest in Mormon Fundamentalism then try ''Under the Banner of Heaven: A Story of Violent Faith'' by Jon Krakauer. For an excellent combination of historical fiction and murder mystery take a look at [[The Suspicions of Mr Whicher by Kate Summerscale]].  You might also enjoy [[Amity and Sorrow by Peggy Riley]].
 {{amazontext|amazon=0552774987}}

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-{{infoboxsort
+{{infobox1
 |title=The 19th Wife
 |author=David Ebershoff
@@ Line 12: / Line 12: @@
 |date=January 2009
 |isbn=978-0552774987
 |sort=19th Wife
 }}

@@ Line 8: / Line 8: @@
 |buy=No
 |borrow=Yes
 |pages=608
 |publisher= Black Swan
@@ Line 34: / Line 33: @@
 If this book has sparked your interest in Mormon Fundamentalism then try ''Under the Banner of Heaven: A Story of Violent Faith'' by Jon Krakauer. For an excellent combination of historical fiction and murder mystery take a look at [[The Suspicions of Mr Whicher by Kate Summerscale]].
-{{amazontext|amazon=0552774987}} {{waterstonestext|waterstones=6519580}}
+{{amazontext|amazon=0552774987}}
 {{toptentext|list=Richard and Judy Shortlist 2009}}

← Older revision	Revision as of 17:15, 24 October 2009
(No difference)