Keeping Mum by Brian Thompson - Revision history

Sue at 08:51, 8 August 2020

2020-08-08T08:51:26Z

Sue at 12:29, 9 April 2018

2018-04-09T12:29:28Z

Sue at 15:01, 26 January 2015

2015-01-26T15:01:28Z

Sue at 15:01, 26 January 2015

2015-01-26T15:01:12Z

Sue at 18:05, 25 November 2012

2012-11-25T18:05:20Z

Keith at 10:08, 7 November 2009

2009-11-07T10:08:10Z

Keith: 1 revision

2009-10-24T17:50:22Z

1 revision

Keith at 15:39, 25 December 2008

2008-12-25T15:39:53Z

New review

{{infobox
|title=Keeping Mum
|author=Brian Thompson
|reviewer=Jill Murphy
|genre=Biography
|summary=Crystal clear prose, a dry sense of humour and a complete lack of self pity elevates Keeping Mum from the swollen ranks of the "poor me" memoirs into something that is really quite sublime. Highly recommended.
|rating=4.5
|buy=Yes
|borrow=Yes
|format=Paperback
|pages=234
|publisher=Atlantic Books
|date=14 Sep 2006
|isbn=978-1843544982
|amazonuk=<amazonuk>1843544989</amazonuk>
|amazonus=<amazonus>1843544989</amazonus>
}}
There are more ''poor me'' memoirs around than you could shake a stick at. David Millionaire Pelzer has a lot to answer for. It's got to the stage where I creep past the autobiography section in a bookshop in as inconspicuous a manner as possible, lest one of the heroic survivors actually reach out from the cover of their therapy-masquerading-as-book and hold me for ransom. Less offensively, wartime childhood memoirs look chirpily on, willing me to pick them up and take them home. They're nice an' all, but one is so often much the same as another.

So, when people started raving about Brian Thompson's ''Keeping Mum'', I was disinclined to believe them. I was wrong. It's spellbinding.

Thompson grew up in London and Cambridge during the 1940s. His parents, Peggy and Bert, were the two people most unsuited to be parents that I've ever read about. While Bert went to war with the RAF, Peggy spent it "running around with the Yanks" and completely neglecting her young son, much to the disapproval of family and friends. My great aunt Helen did much the same thing and is similarly disapproved of by family today, despite her ninety-odd years. Peggy was a manic-depressive and was by turns neglectful of and abusive towards her young son. Bert, once returned from the war, can't see past his wife's infidelities and views the hapless Brian as having collaborated in them. He becomes a weekend visitor only, and spends most of his time either arguing violently with Peggy or resolutely disparaging everything Brian is or does.

It doesn't sound promising, does it? You've probably been there, read that and got several t-shirts to prove it. ''Poor me'' authors probably trapped you in the book shop too. But read on, Macduff.

This isn't a ''poor me'' memoir. It isn't a chirpy, jolliness-in-adversity memoir. It hasn't got its eye on a bank balance and it isn't cathartic therapy for the writer forced upon the reader. ''Keeping Mum'' sparkles with crystal clear, elegant prose. It is clear-sighted and kind-hearted but it is never sentimental. It contains not an ounce of self pity. At moments when a lesser book would be wringing the last, despairing tear from you, ''Keeping Mum'' makes your roar with laughter. And yet, somehow, the laughter doesn't seem out of place.

Thompson's grip on your emotional engagement is a subtle thing. Having laughed when I should have cried, I found myself bursting into real, devastating tears at his sublime definition of jazz, which seemed to me to be a metaphor for his own childhood and, indeed for this book itself:

''Jazz... the steady traffic of vibrant human-interest stories, told in an idiom as powerful as film but without, for the most part, film's saccharine sentimentality. The presumption of every film made in America was that at the end goodness triumphed and the building blocks of the story went back into the box. In jazz, by comparison, the story was left spilled on the floor, to be continued in the next instalment.''

If that doesn't melt your heart, it's made of stone. I can't recommend ''Keeping Mum'' highly enough.

Another wonderfully-written memoir standing clear of the competition is [[Hellfire and Herring]] by Christopher Rush.

{{amazontext|amazon=1843544989}}

{{commenthead}}
{{comment
|name=Diana Sholl
|verb=said
|comment=

I thoroughly enjoyed the review of the above book and will be stepping out to Waterstone's to buy a copy tomorrow. I enjoy most of the reviews on this site as the books chosen are among the best on the market and I am never disappointed when the review leads me to buy a copy.

It is, however, a little unkind to mention other books that have been written by people with bad childhood's as 'poor me' books. Yes, there are alot out at the moment but only because it has been such a closed subject for years but in the great scheme of things there are only a few when compared to the number of years they were absent from the bookshelf. Child abuse is a dreadful thing to suffer from, trust me on this and there is no 'poor me' about it. The writers of these books have not thrust it on the reader, you can chose to buy or not to buy, simple as. What is outrageous is that these human beings have had to experience it in the first place.

It shocks me, sometimes, how flippantly this country takes child neglect.

I hope the above does not sound like a lecture! You site is brilliant and will always have my attention but I felt very strongly on this point and hence the email.

Regards and best wishes
Diana Sholl

}}
{{comment
|name=Jill
|verb=replied
|comment=

Um... yes, I see your point. However, I didn't coin the term, and I do think an industry has grown up around these kinds of memoirs. And the industry is profit-based. I object most strongly to books in which the ghost writing employs the crude literary tactics found in thriller novels to prolong tension and force emotion from the reader. And many of these books do just that. I don't denigrate anybody's experience, neither do I object to those experiences being published. I do, however, object to the experiences being manipulated by literary technique to cause shock and horror. There is no need.

But thank you for all the kind compliments!

}}

@@ Line 4: / Line 4: @@
 |reviewer=Jill Murphy
 |genre=Biography
-|summary=Crystal clear prose, a dry sense of humour and a complete lack of self pity elevates Keeping Mum from the swollen ranks of the "poor me" memoirs into something that is really quite sublime. Highly recommended.
+|summary=Crystal clear prose, a dry sense of humour and a complete lack of self-pity elevates Keeping Mum from the swollen ranks of the "poor me" memoirs into something that is really quite sublime. Highly recommended.
 |rating=4.5
 |buy=Yes
@@ Line 20: / Line 20: @@
 So, when people started raving about Brian Thompson's ''Keeping Mum'', I was disinclined to believe them. I was wrong. It's spellbinding.
-Thompson grew up in London and Cambridge during the 1940s. His parents, Peggy and Bert, were the two people most unsuited to be parents that I've ever read about. While Bert went to war with the RAF, Peggy spent it "running around with the Yanks" and completely neglecting her young son, much to the disapproval of family and friends. My great aunt Helen did much the same thing and is similarly disapproved of by family today, despite her ninety-odd years. Peggy was a manic-depressive and was by turns neglectful of and abusive towards her young son. Bert, once returned from the war, can't see past his wife's infidelities and views the hapless Brian as having collaborated in them. He becomes a weekend visitor only, and spends most of his time either arguing violently with Peggy or resolutely disparaging everything Brian is or does.
+Thompson grew up in London and Cambridge during the 1940s. His parents, Peggy and Bert, were the two people most unsuited to be parents that I've ever read about. While Bert went to war with the RAF, Peggy spent it "running around with the Yanks" and completely neglecting her young son, much to the disapproval of family and friends. My great aunt Helen did much the same thing and is similarly disapproved of by family today, despite her ninety-odd years. Peggy was a manic-depressive and was by turns neglectful of and abusive towards her young son. Bert, once returned from the war, can't see past his wife's infidelities and views the hapless Brian as having collaborated in them. He becomes a weekend visitor only and spends most of his time either arguing violently with Peggy or resolutely disparaging everything Brian is or does.
 It doesn't sound promising, does it? You've probably been there, read that and got several t-shirts to prove it. ''Poor me'' authors probably trapped you in the book shop too. But read on, Macduff.
-This isn't a ''poor me'' memoir. It isn't a chirpy, jolliness-in-adversity memoir. It hasn't got its eye on a bank balance and it isn't cathartic therapy for the writer forced upon the reader. ''Keeping Mum'' sparkles with crystal clear, elegant prose. It is clear-sighted and kind-hearted but it is never sentimental. It contains not an ounce of self pity. At moments when a lesser book would be wringing the last, despairing tear from you, ''Keeping Mum'' makes your roar with laughter. And yet, somehow, the laughter doesn't seem out of place.
+This isn't a ''poor me'' memoir. It isn't a chirpy, jolliness-in-adversity memoir. It hasn't got its eye on a bank balance and it isn't cathartic therapy for the writer forced upon the reader. ''Keeping Mum'' sparkles with crystal clear, elegant prose. It is clear-sighted and kind-hearted but it is never sentimental. It contains not an ounce of self-pity. At moments when a lesser book would be wringing the last, despairing tear from you, ''Keeping Mum'' makes your roar with laughter. And yet, somehow, the laughter doesn't seem out of place.
 Thompson's grip on your emotional engagement is a subtle thing. Having laughed when I should have cried, I found myself bursting into real, devastating tears at his sublime definition of jazz, which seemed to me to be a metaphor for his own childhood and, indeed for this book itself:
-''Jazz... the steady traffic of vibrant human-interest stories, told in an idiom as powerful as film but without, for the most part, film's saccharine sentimentality. The presumption of every film made in America was that at the end goodness triumphed and the building blocks of the story went back into the box. In jazz, by comparison, the story was left spilled on the floor, to be continued in the next instalment.''
+''Jazz... the steady traffic of vibrant human-interest stories, told in an idiom as powerful as film but without, for the most part, film's saccharine sentimentality. The presumption of every film made in America was that at the end goodness triumphed and the building blocks of the story went back into the box. In jazz, by comparison, the story was left spilt on the floor, to be continued in the next instalment.''
 If that doesn't melt your heart, it's made of stone. I can't recommend ''Keeping Mum'' highly enough.
-Another wonderfully-written memoir standing clear of the competition is [[Hellfire and Herring]] by Christopher Rush.
+Another wonderfully-written memoir standing clear of the competition is [[Hellfire and Herring]] by Christopher Rush.  You might also enjoy [[A Corner of Paradise: A love story (with the usual reservations) by Brian Thompson]].
 {{amazontext|amazon=1843544989}}
@@ Line 43: / Line 43: @@
 |comment=I thoroughly enjoyed the review of the above book and will be stepping out to Waterstone's to buy a copy tomorrow. I enjoy most of the reviews on this site as the books chosen are among the best on the market and I am never disappointed when the review leads me to buy a copy.
-It is, however, a little unkind to mention other books that have been written by people with bad childhood's as 'poor me' books. Yes, there are alot out at the moment but only because it has been such a closed subject for years but in the great scheme of things there are only a few when compared to the number of years they were absent from the bookshelf. Child abuse is a dreadful thing to suffer from, trust me on this and there is no 'poor me' about it. The writers of these books have not thrust it on the reader, you can chose to buy or not to buy, simple as. What is outrageous is that these human beings have had to experience it in the first place.
+It is, however, a little unkind to mention other books that have been written by people with bad childhood's as 'poor me' books. Yes, there are a lot out at the moment but only because it has been such a closed subject for years but in the great scheme of things there are only a few when compared to the number of years they were absent from the bookshelf. Child abuse is a dreadful thing to suffer from, trust me on this and there is no 'poor me' about it. The writers of these books have not thrust it on the reader, you can choose to buy or not to buy, simple as. What is outrageous is that these human beings have had to experience it in the first place.
 It shocks me, sometimes, how flippantly this country takes child neglect.
-I hope the above does not sound like a lecture! You site is brilliant and will always have my attention but I felt very strongly on this point and hence the email.
+I hope the above does not sound like a lecture! Your site is brilliant and will always have my attention but I felt very strongly on this point and hence the email.
 Regards and best wishes
@@ Line 55: / Line 55: @@
 |name=Jill
 |verb=replied
-|comment=Um... yes, I see your point. However, I didn't coin the term, and I do think an industry has grown up around these kinds of memoirs. And the industry is profit-based. I object most strongly to books in which the ghost writing employs the crude literary tactics found in thriller novels to prolong tension and force emotion from the reader. And many of these books do just that. I don't denigrate anybody's experience, neither do I object to those experiences being published. I do, however, object to the experiences being manipulated by literary technique to cause shock and horror. There is no need.
+|comment=Um... yes, I see your point. However, I didn't coin the term, and I do think an industry has grown up around these kinds of memoirs. And the industry is profit-based. I object most strongly to books in which the ghostwriting employs the crude literary tactics found in thriller novels to prolong tension and force emotion from the reader. And many of these books do just that. I don't denigrate anybody's experience, neither do I object to those experiences being published. I do, however, object to the experiences being manipulated by literary technique to cause shock and horror. There is no need.
 But thank you for all the kind compliments!
 }}

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-{{infobox
+{{infobox1
 |title=Keeping Mum
 |author=Brian Thompson
@@ Line 12: / Line 12: @@
 |date=September 2006
 |isbn=978-1843544982
-|amazonuk=<amazonuk>1843544989</amazonuk>
+|cover=1843544989
-|amazonus=<amazonus>1843544989</amazonus>
+|aznuk=1843544989
 }}
 There are more ''poor me'' memoirs around than you could shake a stick at. David Millionaire Pelzer has a lot to answer for. It's got to the stage where I creep past the autobiography section in a bookshop in as inconspicuous a manner as possible, lest one of the heroic survivors actually reach out from the cover of their therapy-masquerading-as-book and hold me for ransom. Less offensively, wartime childhood memoirs look chirpily on, willing me to pick them up and take them home. They're nice an' all, but one is so often much the same as another.

@@ Line 8: / Line 8: @@
 |buy=Yes
 |borrow=Yes
 |pages=234
 |publisher=Atlantic Books
@@ Line 35: / Line 34: @@
 {{amazontext|amazon=1843544989}}
 {{commenthead}}
@@ Line 52: / Line 52: @@
 Regards and best wishes
 Diana Sholl
 }}
 {{comment
 |name=Jill
 |verb=replied
-|comment=
+|comment=Um... yes, I see your point. However, I didn't coin the term, and I do think an industry has grown up around these kinds of memoirs. And the industry is profit-based. I object most strongly to books in which the ghost writing employs the crude literary tactics found in thriller novels to prolong tension and force emotion from the reader. And many of these books do just that. I don't denigrate anybody's experience, neither do I object to those experiences being published. I do, however, object to the experiences being manipulated by literary technique to cause shock and horror. There is no need.
 But thank you for all the kind compliments!
 }}

← Older revision	Revision as of 17:50, 24 October 2009
(No difference)