Open main menu

Changes

no edit summary
|buy=Maybe
|borrow=Yes
|paperback=0747586209
|pages=336
|publisher=Bloomsbury Publishing PLC
{{amazontext|amazon=0747586209}}
{{amazonUStext|amazon=1596912367}}
{{commenthead}}
|name=Magda
|verb=said
|comment= It reminds me of my feelings about Kafka. But then, he doesn't really write about people as we know them, does he?
I think genre fiction requires a character one can connect with and like: that's necessary for the escapist function to work. In literary mainstream it's possible to make a fairly compelling book without a likeable character, even with all of them being pretty repulsive (Martin Amis, with everything I read of his which is not much; also McEwan's Amsterdam); but I agree it makes them hard work to read. Is it the reason you don't like Virginia Woolf? (or am I remembering wrongly?).
 
 
 
}}
{{comment
|name=Jill
|verb=replied
|comment= Yes. I wouldn't have minded Restless if it had roused me to really dislike either of the main characters, but it didn't even manage that. I was simply indifferent to them both. You're right. I don't like Virginia Woolf. I can cope with style over substance if it is couched in a humorous book as it is with a lot of cult fiction. But if the whole point of the book is style over substance, then I just think the author would have been better off contemplating their navel in the privacy of their bedroom, not foisting their navel onto the rest of us. Virginia Woolf is the perfect example of this. We have poetry to extend the bounds of language for us, thankyouverymuch. We have novels to engage with.   
}}
{{comment
|name=andyjack55
|verb=said
|comment= But Sal/Eva WAS objective and calculating from the start, as evidenced by her thoughts about Romer when she first meets him and wants to upset his confidence. Why do you need an emotional connection with the characters?  
}}
{{comment
|name=Jill
|verb=replied
|comment= I think people - I perhaps - need to have some kind of reaction to a character in any book for it to create any hold. I don't have to like them; disliking them does just as well. Frankly, I didn't give a fig what happened to either of these women, thus didn't care greatly for the book overall. Perhaps Boyd just can't create credible women, neither of these two were remotely like any women I know.
}}
[[Category:Thrillers]]