132,602
edits
Changes
I Don't Know What to Call My Cat by Simon Philip and Ella Bailey (view source)
Revision as of 14:01, 11 August 2020
, 14:01, 11 August 2020no edit summary
|reviewer=Sam Tyler
|genre=For Sharing
|summary=A mysterious cat arrives at the door; one little girl sets out to discover its name in this fun story that has some great illustrations, but loses its way, plot -wise.
|rating=3.5
|buy=Maybe
Getting a new pet is rife with things that you have to do. Where will they sleep? What will they eat? And, of course, what on Earth are you going to call them? Giving a pet the right name when they are tiny can be an issue in itself – a cute fluffy dog can grow into a massive hound called Fluffy, or you could call your male cat Claire. Perhaps it would help if the animal itself could tell you what name they want?
When a new cat arrives at the door it is a tricky proposition to give them a name. Do they want to be called Catkins, Cutesy, Boots, Mittens? None of these names seem seems to fit so the new cat leaves home in a huff. Can the little girl entice the cat back with a new and even better name, or perhaps she should just visit the zoo and choose a new pet entirely?
''I Don't Know What to Call My Cat'' is a very cute book that seems to be made up of two slightly different stories that don't gel perfectly. One is a Seuss -like story about a young girl naming her cat, she spends pages thinking about what to call it until she realises there is one major fact she has missed out – is it a he or a she? The second part of the book is when there is a gorilla in the midst.
At its best , the book is all about trying to find a name for a mysterious little cat. Philip has a very straight sense of humour that amuses the reader as the little girl tries her best to stoically name the cat. However, it's Bailey's illustrations that really steal the show as she is able to portray what is happening wonderfully. Our heroine is a little chaotic so Bailey fills her house with objects that are great fun to explore. Some of the best pages are just a list of names with the type of cat that may be associated with them.
Where the book loses its way is towards the end. Our mysterious cat leaves and instead , we are introduced to a gorilla as a pet. Steve the Gorilla is an amiable enough chap, but his inclusion in the story just feels like it is from another book. There is no reason to have several pages given over to a side line, sideline when the book is only 32 pages long.
What remains is a visually attractive book with some fun ideas that cat lovers , in particular , will adore. However, due to a significant chunk of the book being given over to a redundant storyline, it does not quite have the impact that it could have.
One cat that does know his name is [[Augustus and His Smile by Catherine Rayner]]. You might also enjoy [[At The Animal Ball by Ella Bailey]].
{{amazontext|amazon=1471124134}}