On the Edge by Jenny Pitman
|On the Edge by Jenny Pitman|
|Category: General Fiction|
|Reviewer: Sue Magee|
|Summary: The horse racing background is very well done but the plot and characterisation are all but non-existent. It's tosh but worth borrowing if you have an interest in horse racing and point-to-pointing - and suffer from insomnia.|
|Buy? No||Borrow? Maybe|
|Pages: 256||Date: November 2002|
I didn't borrow this book from the library with any great expectations, but I've an interest in horse racing and a need for something to read when I can't sleep.
Jan Hardy's husband dies of cancer, leaving her with two young children and a farm in Wales. She's successfully trained point-to-point horses and decides that she'll sell the farm and buy a property closer to her parents with the intention of making a living as a trainer. The book takes us through the period when she's trying to establish herself and the problems she faces. There's a stereotypical mother-in-law, a dubious auctioneer, some doting men and all the usual riff-raff and gentlemen of the racing world.
If you've an interest in racing then this is a reasonable enough story. Jenny Pitman was a champion race-horse trainer and one of the first women to penetrate this very masculine world. The detail about racing - from point-to-pointing through to the professional courses - is fascinating and accurate. There's insight into the running of racing stables from, if not the horse's mouth, then certainly the trainer's. It's a hard life on the bottom rungs of the ladder and it's a business with more than its fair share of charlatans and rogues. There's always going to be a fund of good stories. I suspect we'll hear more of them in the sequels.
Jenny Pitman has wisely written about what she knows best. Here it's not only the world of horse racing. After the failure of her first marriage she was left with two young sons to raise and considerable financial difficulties, so she knows the stresses and strains that are involved. We should be onto a winner then, shouldn't we?
Well, no, we're not. The facts are all there but there's very little in the way of emotion. The book opens with Jan Hardy at her husband's funeral but I've felt more grief from people doing a supermarket shop. Even after the funeral she's so calm and business-like that I began to dislike her. She meets grief and tragedy with not even a hint of a tear. Her mother-in-law is painted as bitter but she's just watched her only son die and is going to be left on her own when Jan takes her beloved grandchildren to Gloucestershire. Can we really expect cheerfulness?
None of the characters seem rounded or even plausible. Annabel, her assistant, is independently wealthy and moves to Gloucestershire just to help Jan. Despite playing an important part in the story I felt that I knew her no better at the end than I did at the beginning. She's a shadowy presence ready to step in when the plot requires her. I think Eddie, dilettante son of a rich man who goes broke, is supposed to be the love interest, but in reality he just seemed to be the mandatory good-looking male. There's a builder who dotes on Jan, but his doting seems to take the form of doing a lot of work for no more return than the pleasure of doing the work. The children behave - always - and there's always someone there to look after them whilst Jan goes off to the races.
The plot is straggly. Problems arise. Problems are solved. Some take longer than others and some still have loose ends dangling ready to be picked up in the inevitable sequel. Some of the solutions seem a little implausible. Rather than describe the book as having a plot I'd say that there's a series of short stories loosely cobbled together by having common characters and settings.
I suppose I shouldn't be too hard on Mrs Pitman. Once your training career is over and you're down to after-dinner speaking as a way of making ends meet, what's a girl to do other than follow the likes of Dick Francis and John Francome into the world of horse-racing fiction? She's better than Francome (but that's not difficult) but not as good as Francis at his best. The book's recommended (cautiously) if you're interested in the world of horse racing. It's not recommended if you like your fiction tightly plotted with rounded characters. Either way it's not worth buying: support your local library if you must read it!
It was a cure for insomnia for a couple of nights though.
You can read more book reviews or buy On the Edge by Jenny Pitman at Amazon.co.uk
You can read more book reviews or buy On the Edge by Jenny Pitman at Amazon.com.
Like to comment on this review?
Just send us an email and we'll put the best up on the site.